First Evidence of Voicemail in Nature

Dutch biologists have discovered that insects can use plants as green phones for communication with other bugs.

Ragwort plants show to act as phones that insects can even use to store voicemail messages in the soil (Olga Kostenko / Netherlands Institute of Ecology)

A new study, published in the journal Ecology Letters, shows that through those same plants insects are also able to leave ‘voicemail’ messages in the soil. Herbivorous insects store their voicemails via their effects on soil fungi. The researchers from the Netherlands Institute of Ecology and Wageningen University have found this unique messaging service in the ragwort plant.

A few years ago, the scientists discovered that soil-dwelling and aboveground insects are able to communicate with each other using the plant as a telephone. Insects eating plant roots change the chemical composition of the leaves, causing the plant to release volatile signals into the air. This can convince aboveground insects to select another food plant in order to avoid competition and to escape from poisonous defense compounds in the plant. But the impact doesn’t stop there.

The new study shows that insects leave a specific legacy that remains in the soil after they have fed on a plant. And future plants growing on that same spot can pick up these signals from the soil and pass them on to other insects. Those messages are really specific: the new plant can tell whether the former one was suffering from leaf-eating caterpillars or from root-eating insects.

“The new plants are actually decoding a voicemail message from the past to the next generation of plant-feeding insects, and their enemies,” said first author Dr Olga Kostenko of the Netherlands Institute of Ecology. “The insects are re-living the past. This message from the past strongly influences the growth and possibly also the behavior of these bugs. Today’s insect community is influenced by the messages from past seasons.”

The team grew ragwort plants in a greenhouse and exposed them to leaf-eating caterpillars or root-feeding beetle larvae. Then they grew new plants in the same soil and exposed them to insects again.

“What we discovered is that the composition of fungi in the soil changed greatly and depended on whether the insect had been feeding on roots or leaves,” Dr Kostenko said. “These changes in fungal community, in turn, affected the growth and chemistry of the next batch of plants and therefore the insects on those plants.”

Growth and palatability of new plants in the same soil thus mirrored the condition of the previous plant. In this way, a new plant can pass down the soil legacy or message from the past to caterpillars and their enemies.

“How long are these voicemail messages kept in the soil? That’s what I also would like to know! We’re working on this, and on the question of how widespread this phenomenon is in nature,” Dr Kostenko concluded.


Bibliographic information: Kostenko O. et al. 2012. Legacy effects of aboveground-belowground interactions. Ecology Letters. Article first published online on May 17, 2012; doi: 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2012.01801.x