Modern Humans did not Settle in Asia before Toba Eruption 74,000 Years Ago

New genetic research reported in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences refutes a recent theory that there is evidence for the presence of modern humans in southern Asia before the super-eruption of the Mount Toba volcano in Sumatra.

Artist’s impression of the Toba super-eruption (

Artist’s impression of the Toba super-eruption (

The Toba super-eruption – one of the most catastrophic events since humans evolved – happened around 74,000 years ago.

In 2005, Professor Martin Richards from the University of Huddersfield led research which used mitochondrial DNA evidence to show that anatomically modern humans dispersed from their Africa homeland via a ‘southern coastal route’ from the Horn and through Arabia, about 60,000 years ago – after the Toba eruption.

However, archaeologists excavating in India then claimed to have found evidence that modern humans were there before the eruption – possibly as early as 120,000 years ago, much earlier than Europe or the Near East were colonized. These findings, based on the discovery of stone tools below a layer of Toba ash, were published in 2007.

Now Prof Richards has published his rebuttal of this theory. In doing so, he and his colleagues have been able to draw on a much greater body of DNA evidence that was available for the earlier study.

“One of the things we didn’t have in 2005 was very much evidence from India in the way of mitochondrial sequences. Now, with a lot of people doing sequencing and depositing material in databases there are about 1,000 sequences from India,” Prof Richards explained.

By using the mitochondrial DNA of today’s populations and working backwards, and by drawing on a wide variety of other evidence and research, the team was able to make much more precise estimates for the arrival of modern humans in India.

The evidence suggests dispersal from Africa and settlement in India no earlier than 60,000 years ago.

“We also argue that close archaeological similarities between African and Indian stone-tool technologies after 70,000 years ago, as well as features such as beads and engravings, suggest that the slightly later Indian material had an African source,” Prof Richards said.

“There were people in India before the Toba eruption, because there are stone tools there, but they could have been Neanderthals – or some other pre-modern population.”

“The replacement of the presumably archaic humans living previously in South Asia by modern people with these new technologies appears analogous to the replacement of Neanderthals by modern humans in Europe and western Asia 50,000 – 40,000 years ago.”


Bibliographic information: Paul Mellars et al. Genetic and archaeological perspectives on the initial modern human colonization of southern Asia. PNAS, published online June 10, 2013; doi: 10.1073/pnas.1306043110